New York (AP) – The New York Court of Appeal on Thursday dumped the huge punishment for civil fraud of President Donald Trump while asserting a judge’s finding that he has exaggerated his wealth for decades. The decision delighted Donald Trump from a potential half-billion dollar fine, but forbids him and his two greatest sons from serving in corporate leadership for several years.
The decision came seven months after the Republican returned to the White House. A call of five judges in the Appellate Department at the New York Middle Level said the sentence that was standing to cost Trump more than $ 515 million and shake his real estate empire was “excessive”.
After finding Trump, engaged in fraud from the rough -paying financial statements that went to the creditors and insurers, Judge Arthur Engoron ordered him to pay $ 355 million. With interest, the amount exceeded $ 515 million.
The common – combined with penalties imposed on some other leaders of the Trump organization, including the sons of Trump Eric and Donald Jr. – now exceeds $ 527 million, with interest.
“Excessive” fine
“While disturbed by the court is well designed to limit the business culture of the defendants, the order for a disorder of the court, which directs that the defendants pay almost half a million dollars in the state of New York, is an excessive fine that violates the lively amendment of the United States.” Taking the fierce repairs.
Other Engoron penalties, upheld by the Court of Appeal, were on a pause during Trump’s appeal and he was able to retain the money by posting a $ 175 million bond.
The court, which divided the merits of the case and the finding of Fraud of Engoron, rejected the punishment in its entirety, leaving the way to appeal before the highest court of the state, the Court of Appeal. Trump and his co-defenders, the judges wrote, may seek to expand the pause on any penalty.
The panel was sharply divided, issuing 323 pages of coherent and disagreeing opinions without a majority. More recently, some judges approved parts of their colleagues’ findings while denied others, allowing the court to rule.
Two judges wrote that they believe that the case of New York Prosecutor General James James against Trump and his companies was justified and that she proved her case, but the punishment was too severe. One wrote that James exceeded his legitimate authority in the broadcast of the case, saying that if one of Trump’s lender felt lied to, they could judge him and no one did it.
A judge writes that Engoron made a mistake by making a decision before the process began, that the prosecutor General had proven that Trump was involved in fraud.
The Court of Appeal, the State Court of Appeal, took an unusually long time to rule, weighing Trump’s complaint for nearly 11 months after the oral arguments last fall. Typically, appeals are resolved after a few weeks or several months.
James said that the businessman turned into a politician was involved in “lie, infidelity and striking fraud.” Her service had no immediate comment after the decision on Thursday.
Claims for policy in a game
Trump and his co-defenders have denied misconduct. In a six -minute summary of species after a monthly hearing, Trump announced in January 2024 that he was an “innocent man” and the case was “fraud for me”. The Republican repeatedly maintained the case and the sentence was the political movements of James and Engoron, both Democrats.
The Trump Ministry of Justice has called on James for records related to the case, among other documents, as part of the investigation whether it violates the president’s civil rights. James’s personal lawyer Abbot D. Lowell said the investigation into the fraud case was “the most broad and desperate example of this administration conducting the President’s political retaliation campaign.”
Trump and his lawyers said his financial reports were not deceptive as they came with a refusal of responsibility, noting that they were not audited. The defense also noted that bankers and insurers independently evaluate the numbers and the loans were repaid.
Despite such discrepancies as the triple of his penthouse size on Trump Tower, he said the financial statements, if nothing else, with a low forecast for his wealth.
During an appellate hearing last September, Trump’s lawyers claim that many of the accusations of the case are too old, the claim they made unsuccessfully before the trial. The defense also claims that James is abusing a Consumer Protection Act to judge Trump and incorrectly polishes the private business deals that are satisfactory for participants.
State attorneys said the law in question was applied to deceptive or illegal business behavior, whether it was aimed at daily users or large corporations. Although Trump insists that no one has been hurt by the financial statements, the state claims that the numbers have led creditors to make higher loans and that honest borrowers lose when others play their net values.
The state claims that the verdict is based on sufficient evidence and that the scale of the criminal comparison of Trump’s profits, including his profits on property funded with loans and interest he saves by receiving favorable conditions offered to rich borrowers.
Legal obstacles
The civil fraud case was just one of the few legal obstacles to Trump while he was campaigning, won and split into a second term as president.
On January 10, he was sentenced to his criminal silent money to what was known as unconditional discharge, leaving his sentence on books, but saved him from prison, probation, fine or other punishment. He appealed the sentence.
In December, the Federal Court of Appeal upheld the jury’s finding that Trump sexually abused writer E. Jean Carroll in the mid-1990s and later slandered it, confirming a $ 5 million decision against him. The Court of Appeal refused to review in June. Trump can still try to make the Supreme Court hearing his complaint.
Trump also appealed a subsequent sentence, which requires him to pay Carol $ 83.3 million for additional slander demands.
___
Follow President Donald Trump’s AP at https://apnews.com/hub/donald-trump.